Skip to content
Research한국어

Compare

Magnesium Glycinate vs Magnesium L-Threonate

The trials reviewed here compared each product with placebo, not with the other form. They do not establish which is better for sleep. Compare the study outcomes and magnesium amounts separately.

Magnesium Glycinate vs Magnesium L-Threonate
Magnesium GlycinateMagnesium L-Threonate
CategoryMineralsMinerals
Best timeBedtimeBedtime
FoodWith or without foodWith or without food
Common dose (elemental magnesium)100–350 mg100–150 mg
Upper limit
350 mg/day

UL applies to all supplemental magnesium combined (not food); mainly to prevent diarrhea.

350 mg/day

UL applies to all supplemental magnesium combined (not food); mainly to prevent diarrhea.

SolubilityWater-solubleWater-soluble
DescriptionMagnesium bound to glycine. A four-week placebo-controlled trial in adults reporting poor sleep found a small improvement in self-reported insomnia severity. This does not establish long-term benefit or superiority over other magnesium forms.Developed following animal brain-magnesium research. A short, industry-funded trial improved some sleep measures, but the overall insomnia-severity treatment-by-time effect was not significant. It supplies relatively little elemental magnesium per gram.
Timing noteUsually taken in the evening or at bedtime; it's gentle on the stomach, so food is optional.Commonly taken in the evening, sometimes split morning and evening.
Forms to look for
  • Check elemental magnesium per serving — glycinate is only about 14% magnesium by weight
  • Fully reacted (buffered products may contain oxide)
  • Magtein® (the studied ingredient)
  • Labels often show the threonate compound (about 2 g/day), which is under 10% magnesium

Common product or study range — not a personal recommendation. Upper limits are ceilings, not targets.

If you take both

NoteStrong evidence

Usually unnecessary — both supply magnesium, and the amounts add up.

Pick one form, or add up the elemental magnesium on both labels.

Open these two in the checker

What the sleep trials actually tested

A focused review of two trials and a correction, not an exhaustive review or a personal recommendation. The amounts below describe study methods; they are not instructions for what to take.

Bisglycinate: a small change in self-reported insomnia

Who and what
Schuster et al. (2025) randomized 155 adults aged 18–65 reporting poor sleep. For four weeks, the active group received 250 mg elemental magnesium daily as bisglycinate, supplying about 1.5 g glycine, versus placebo. The primary outcome analysis included 153 participants who completed the baseline questionnaire (77 in the magnesium group and 76 on placebo); 134 participants completed all four weeks.
Results
The statistical model estimated mean reductions in Insomnia Severity Index scores of 3.9 points with magnesium and 2.3 with placebo. The between-group difference in mean change was 1.6 points (p=0.049; small effect, Cohen’s d=0.2). This average difference is not a prediction of an individual’s improvement or a treatment success rate. Other psychological outcomes did not differ significantly.
Limits
Sleep was self-reported, without actigraphy or polysomnography. The study cannot separate magnesium’s effect from the glycine supplied with it. It excluded several conditions and medicines, including renal insufficiency and sleep-affecting medication.
Funding and disclosure
Funded by the University of Hannover institute conducting the study. One author disclosed nutraceutical-industry research and honoraria relationships.

L-threonate: selected measures improved, not every outcome

Who and what
Hausenblas et al. (2024) randomized 80 adults aged 35–55 with self-reported sleep problems; 76 were analyzed. The 21-day trial compared 1 g/day of magnesium L-threonate (about 75 mg elemental magnesium) with placebo, using questionnaires and an Oura ring.
Results
Some wearable sleep scores and daytime measures favored threonate. For overall insomnia severity, both groups improved and the treatment-by-time interaction was not significant (p=0.39). Selected positive scores do not mean every sleep outcome improved.
Limits
A short trial in selected adults; wearable scores are not a laboratory sleep study. The 2025 correction states that the trial was registered retrospectively, after it had been conducted.
Funding and disclosure
AIDP commissioned and funded the trial. The correction discloses patents and paid relationships for three authors; it does not report a change to the trial results.

Compound weight is not the magnesium amount

In the threonate trial, 1,000 mg of the compound supplied about 75 mg of elemental magnesium. Those numbers describe the same material; they are not two amounts to add. The bisglycinate trial supplied 250 mg of elemental magnesium in two capsules. The comparison table uses elemental magnesium. Check your own product’s magnesium amount and serving size rather than using a compound’s front-label weight or copying a study dose.

Neither trial tested these two forms together. Different participants, doses, durations and outcome measures prevent a simple winner-by-numbers comparison. Both studies were short and involved selected adults; they do not settle long-term safety or treatment of a diagnosed sleep disorder.

Research note checked:

Common questions

What is the difference between Magnesium Glycinate and Magnesium L-Threonate?

Magnesium Glycinate: Magnesium bound to glycine. A four-week placebo-controlled trial in adults reporting poor sleep found a small improvement in self-reported insomnia severity. This does not establish long-term benefit or superiority over other magnesium forms. Magnesium L-Threonate: Developed following animal brain-magnesium research. A short, industry-funded trial improved some sleep measures, but the overall insomnia-severity treatment-by-time effect was not significant. It supplies relatively little elemental magnesium per gram.

Can I take Magnesium Glycinate and Magnesium L-Threonate together?

Usually unnecessary — both supply magnesium, and the amounts add up.

Last reviewed Sourced from NIH fact sheets and peer-reviewed studies.How we make this contentReport an error